Individual Application Right Usage: Guide to ECHR Application

🚨 Current Protocol Changes

Protocol changes made in ECHR system have significant effects on individual application process and admissibility criteria. For current effective dates and details, official sources such as Council of Europe and Official Gazette should be followed and applicable provisions for your concrete file should be confirmed from these sources.

Introduction

Individual application right, which is one of most important elements of European Convention on Human Rights, is an effective protection tool for citizens against human rights violations. This right is regulated in Article 34 of the Convention and is an important legal mechanism that Turkish citizens can also benefit from. In this comprehensive guide, we will examine in detail how individual application right is used, application process and points to consider. Getting professional help may help increase legal quality of application and reduce risk of procedural errors; however whether an application will be accepted or not always depends on characteristics of concrete event and independent discretion of European Court of Human Rights (ECHR).

Main Content Section

Legal Bases of Individual Application Right

Individual application right is regulated in Article 34 of European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). This right enables citizens of states party to the convention to apply directly to ECHR by claiming that one of rights guaranteed in convention is violated.

📜 ECHR Article 34

“Individual Application Right:” The Court may receive applications from any person, non-governmental organisation or group of individuals claiming to be the victim of a violation by one of the High Contracting Parties of the rights set forth in the Convention or the Protocols thereto.

🇹🇷 Constitution Article 90

International Treaties: Turkey signed ECHR in 1954 and ratified it in 1954. The Convention is directly applicable in domestic law pursuant to Article 90 of Constitution.

Conditions for Benefiting from Application Right

Certain conditions must be fulfilled to benefit from individual application right. These conditions determine admissibility of application.

⚖️ Exhaustion of Domestic Remedies

Before making an application, you must have used all judicial authorities in Turkey. This includes all paths including individual application to Constitutional Court.

⏰ Time Limit Condition

In current practice, pursuant to Protocol No. 15, individual application period has been reduced to a shorter forfeiture period as a rule; in previous periods six-month period rule was applied. For determination of which period applies for your concrete file and for applications between which dates, Protocol No. 15, ECHR Article 35 and relevant jurisprudence must be examined directly. 📅 2025 Change: With Protocol No. 15, admissibility criteria were rearranged and time condition was optimized.

🎯 Seriousness and Admissibility

Your application must be serious and claim of rights violation must be supported by concrete evidence. Applications clearly devoid of basis are rejected.

Stages of Application Process

Individual application process to ECHR consists of certain stages. Every stage is important and must be completed correctly. Getting detailed information on ECHR application process and admissibility criteria during application process increases your application’s chance of acceptance.

📝 1. Application Preparation

Application form is filled completely, rights violation claim is explained in detail within scope of European Convention on Human Rights (ETS No. 5) Article 34; necessary documents are collected and evidence is completed; application petition is supported by legal reasoning and all legal procedure steps are completed.

📤 2. Application Submission

Application form is sent to ECHR (Conseil de l’Europe, 67075 Strasbourg Cedex, France) address by post in signed manner; electronic communication (eComms) platform can be used only upon Court’s invitation; application registration number and confirmation document are kept for tracking; sending by registered or international cargo is recommended.

🔍 3. Preliminary Examination

Court’s legal advisors (jurisconsultes) subject application to preliminary examination; admissibility criteria are checked within scope of Protocol No. 15 (OG: 04.08.2021/31559); is domestic law remedies exhausted, is time condition fulfilled, is application manifestly ill-founded confirmed; if deemed necessary additional information is requested from applicant.

⚖️ 4. Admissibility Decision

Committee of judges or chamber decides whether application is admissible or not; in case of inadmissibility process ends with ECHR Article 35 justification; if accepted file passes to examination on merits stage; result of admissibility decision is notified to applicant by official letter; time for giving these decisions may vary according to court’s workload and nature of file and current practice regarding concrete application should be evaluated separately.

📋 5. Examination Stage

Admissible applications are examined in detail; parties (applicant and state) submit their opinions; if Court requests witness hearing, expert report or hearing is held; friendly settlement is proposed between parties within scope of Rule 54; government submits its defense pursuant to Internal Rules Article 38.

📜 6. Decision Stage

Court decides whether there is rights violation or not; if violation is detected compensation amount suitable to Constitutional Court, App. No: 2014/3986, Decision: 2015/54 (28.05.2015) jurisprudence is determined; national measures are envisaged parallel to Law No. 6216 (OG: 04.02.2016/29620); decision becomes final and is subjected to Committee of Ministers supervision.

Required Documents and Preparation

Preparation of correct documents carries critical importance for a successful application. Missing or wrong documents may cause rejection of application.

📄 Basic Application Documents

• Filled application form
• ID photocopy
• Residence document
• Power of attorney (if Attorney exists)

⚖️ Judicial Documents

• All court decisions
• Constitutional Court decision
• Court of Cassation or Council of State decisions
• Execution proceedings (if any)

📊 Evidence Documents

• Photos and videos
• Witness statements
• Expert reports
• Doctor reports

Application Strategies and Tips

Developing correct strategy is important for a successful application. Here are some important tips: 🎯 Clear and Explicit Expression: Explain rights violation claim clearly in European Convention on Human Rights (ETS No. 5) Article 34 standard; avoid complex expressions, unnecessary legal jargons; support concrete event details with date, place, persons and actions; state which rights are violated within scope of which articles. 📋 Chronological Narration: Tell events in detail in chronological order; do not skip details; explain domestic remedies (1st instance court, appeal, cassation, individual application) completely; state dates, merit and decision numbers of all court decisions; emphasize compliance with time condition relevant to Protocol No. 15. 🔗 Similar Decisions: Reference ECHR decisions related to your application (from HUDOC database); state precedent decisions regarding Turkey; show compliance with Venice Commission Rule of Law Checklist (2023) criteria; use Court’s settled case-law as support. ⚖️ Professional Help: If possible get Attorney support knowing Law No. 6216 and ECHR procedures; professional legal representation contributes to strengthening of legal argumentation of application and reduction of risk of procedural deficiency since application process is complex and requires expertise.

Frequently Made Mistakes and Things to Avoid

Some mistakes frequently made during applications may cause rejection of application:

❌ Time Error

Wrong calculation of individual application period envisaged after Protocol No. 15 or six-month period rule regarding previous period may lead to application being deemed inadmissible.

❌ Domestic Remedies Not Exhausted

Making application without using all domestic remedies is inadmissible pursuant to ECHR Article 35/1; Constitutional Court individual application (Law No. 6216) must be exhausted; appeal period must not be missed; ECHR application cannot be made without using effective remedies.

❌ Insufficient Evidence

Not submitting concrete evidence (court decisions, witness statements, photos, videos, expert reports, medical documents) supporting rights violation claim leads to rejection of application.

❌ Clearly Groundless Application

It is inevitable that claims which cannot be proven in any way (manifestly ill-founded), applications made for rights not defined in ECHR articles, claims contradicting Court’s previous jurisprudence, based on subjective personal complaints or not presented with legal basis are rejected.

FAQ Section

Who can use individual application right? Citizens of states party to European Convention on Human Rights. Turkish citizens can also benefit from this right.

What conditions are required for application? Exhaustion of domestic remedies, compliance with application period envisaged pursuant to European Convention on Human Rights and relevant protocols and application being serious.

How long does application process take? It varies significantly according to court’s workload, priority status of application and complexity of file.

Is application result binding? ECHR decisions are binding for respondent states.

Is Attorney necessary during application? It is not mandatory but getting support from an expert Attorney is beneficial.

In which situations application cannot be made? If domestic remedies are not exhausted, application period is passed or application is not serious.

How is application made? Application is made via ECHR’s website and application form is filled.

Where is application form found? It can be downloaded from ECHR’s official website echr.coe.int.

What are rights violation types? Freedom of expression, fair trial, prohibition of torture, privacy of private life etc.

How does process work after application? After application is accepted parties submit their opinions, Court examines evidence.

How is compensation amount determined? According to nature of case, violation duration, damage suffered by user and living standards in Europe.

Expert Legal Support: Individual application right usage is a field requiring quite expertise. Professional support helps healthy management of application process and reduction of procedural error risks.

---

Professional Legal Support

Contact us for professional legal assistance on this matter.

📞 Call Now: +90 554 192 47 20

📧 Email: info@avukatfevziyaskir.com

📍 Address: Opposite the Courthouse, Karatay/Konya, Turkey

⚖️ Attorney Fevzi Yaşkir - Licensed attorney at Konya Bar Association providing legal consultation and case management services for international clients.