Expropriation Value Increase Lawsuit in Turkey

Expropriation (Kamulaştırma) is the legal power of the State to take private property for public use (e.g., building a road, dam, school, or power line) in exchange for compensation. While the State has the right to take the land, the Constitution (Article 46) guarantees that it must pay the “actual value” (Gerçek Karşılık) of the property in advance. However, in practice, the initial price offered by the Administration is often based on conservative tax values and is far below the real market value. This is where the Value Increase Lawsuit (Bedel Artırım Davası) comes into play.

The Expropriation Process

1. Public Interest Decision: The relevant authority (Municipality, Ministry, or Karayolları) makes a formal decision that the land is needed.
2. Purchasing Committee: A committee estimates a price.
3. Notification & Invitation: The Administration invites the owner to a negotiation meeting (Uzlaşma Görüşmesi).
   • Tip: Attending is mandatory, but accepting the price is not.
4. Negotiation Failure: If you reject the offer (which is common, as offers are low), the negotiation fails.
5. Appraisal Lawsuit (Bedel Tespit Tescil): The Administration files a lawsuit against YOU to determine the price and register the land in its name.

Important Note: Unlike other lawsuits, here the State sues you, but essentially you are the one trying to prove the price should be higher.

How is Value Determined?

The court appoints an Expert Panel (Bilirkişi Heyeti) consisting of engineers and realtors. Their report is the single most important factor. The valuation criteria differ by land type:

A. For Land (Arsa) - Urban Plots

Urban land (Arsa) is valued based on Precedent Sales (Emsal Satışlar). The experts look for:

• Similar properties in the same neighborhood.
• Sold around the same date (just before expropriation).
• With a declared official sales price. If your neighbor sold their land for 10 million TL, and the state offers you 2 million TL for the same size, this precedent is your strongest weapon.

B. For Fields (Tarla) - Agricultural Land

Agricultural land is valued based on the Income Capitalization Method (Net Gelir Yöntemi).

• What crops grow there? (Wheat, Corn, Apples?)
• What is the annual yield?
• What are the production costs?
• The net profit is multiplied by a capitalization rate (usually 20) to find the land value.

Kamulaştırmasız El Atma (De Facto Confiscation)

Sometimes the State is lazy. It builds a road across your land without any official expropriation process or notification. This is illegal “de facto confiscation.” In this case, you are not waiting for them. You file a Compensation Lawsuit for Confiscation without Expropriation.

• Remedy: You receive the current market value of the land.
• Ecrimisil: You also receive “occupation compensation” (rent) for the retroactive period the state used your land illegally (up to 5 years).

Conclusion

Expropriation cases are a battle of numbers. The Administration’s Attorneys will try to lower the price using low tax records. Your defense requires a proactive approach: gathering real precedent sales, ensuring the “objective value increase attributes” (proximity to city, road frontage) are calculated, and challenging incorrect expert reports. Do not settle for less than your property’s true worth.

Professional Legal Support

Contact us for professional legal assistance on this matter.

📞 Call Now: +90 554 192 47 20

📧 Email: info@avukatfevziyaskir.com

📍 Address: Opposite the Courthouse, Karatay/Konya, Turkey

⚖️ Attorney Fevzi Yaşkir - Licensed attorney at Konya Bar Association providing legal consultation and case management services for international clients.